LA GRANDE — Union County on Wednesday added only two new cases of COVID-19 to its total, but the 242 still is good enough for the fifth most in the state.
The county on Tuesday added 119 confirmed cases of COVID-19, making it the hotspot in the state, according to the Oregon Health Authority. The spike prompted business to shut doors and the city of La Grande to close parks. The Union County Board of Commissioners voted to recommend rolling back to Phase 1 guidelines.
The board of commissioners met Wednesday morning via a Zoom call to address the community’s concerns about the outbreak. Members of the Center for Human Development, the Union County Sheriff’s Office, La Grande Police Department and the Incident Management Team’s J.B. Brock sat in on the meeting to provide further information and recommendations. In addition to recommending the roll back to Phase 1, commissioners voted to recommend wearing masks.
The two motions are only recommendations. Commissioner Matt Scarfo said the board is looking into what power it has to enforce and regulate phases and mask use. Commissioner Donna Beverage said she would rather trust residents to voluntarily enact Phase 1 guidelines.
La Grande Police Chief Gary Bell and Union County Sheriff Boyd Rasmussen confirmed there will be no formal enforcement of guidelines.
“I know some would like to see us take more heavy-handed enforcement action, but it is really difficult at this time,” Bell said. “These are good people.”
The two top local law enforcement officers said their agencies will continue to look into complaints about people not following guidelines and make recommendations to those who don’t to reconsider their actions to keep the community safe.
“I think we are prepared as any community to deal with this,” Rasmussen said. “We were put on the map with how this has happened and we are on the map on how we are going to handle this.”
Public Health Administrator Carrie Brogoitti said what happens next in the county depends on every member of the community stepping up.
“We don’t have a reliable treatment or vaccine,” she said. “So the tools we have to use are the preventative measures.”
“This is a big deal,” La Grande Mayor Steve Clements said Wednesday. “It’s a community crisis that needs to be handled by community engagement. Everyone in the community has a responsibility to help stop the spread of the virus. I have tremendous faith in the professionals we have in place.”
Source of outbreak quiet
Thomas Jeanne, deputy state health officer and epidemiologist, said during a Tuesday afternoon call with media members that 236 cases were connected to Lighthouse Pentecostal Church in Island City. The outbreak is officially the largest to date in Oregon.
The church held “drive-up” services before the May 15 Phase 1 reopening. Videos of the services show church leaders and dozens of parishioners ignored social distancing recommendations, did not wear face coverings and often jostled and touched each other in group prayers. The church sometime after Monday removed those videos from its page.
James Parker, a pastor at Lighthouse Pentecostal Church, posted a video Tuesday morning to the church’s Facebook page with a message to members:
“Our fruit will show that what we did is the right thing. And more people need to do what we did. And the more people that do the right thing, the easier it’s going to be for the rest of the world to combat this, this pandemic that we’re going through. Umm, we shouldn’t hide from life’s circumstances. You got to stand up on your feet and you got to face them. That’s what we do. That’s what we’ll continue to do.”
Since then, the church’s Facebook page was down Wednesday but operating again Thursday. The Observer tried multiple times to contact someone at the church, and on Wednesday the church’s phone would not accept voicemail.
Spike could lead to rollback
Gov. Kate Brown said Tuesday the state could reverse the “reopening” of Union County if the sharp spike in positive cases of COVID-19 isn’t contained.
The state reported 278 new infections Tuesday, surpassing the previous single-day record of 184 cases set Monday. There were 120 more cases Wednesday.
Union County’s 119 new cases Tuesday drove the spike, according to the official count from Oregon Health Authority and Center for Human Development, the nonprofit that oversees public health in the county.
Health officials on Tuesday said they believe they tested all the congregation members who might be infected and hope trace contacting will keep the outbreak in check, but added “all options are on the table,” including removing the county from Phase 2 reopening — which would mark the first reversal since the state plan to lift pandemic restrictions began last month.
Jeanne on Tuesday noted five people were in the hospital with COVID-19 but he was not able to share how many patients are in the ICU or on ventilators “due to privacy concerns.” The Oregon Health Authority, Grande Ronde Hospital nor the Center for Human Development would provide hospitalization information Wednesday. The OHA statewide update showed 929 individuals in Oregon have been hospitalized due to the coronavirus since the start of the pandemic. That number was up 17 from the 912 shown in Tuesday’s update.
Nearly 1% of the population in the county now has COVID-19, making it by far the hardest-hit section of the state per capita.
“If I could say one thing to people it’s stay calm take responsibility stay home if you can and wear a mask when out in public,” Clements said.
Hospital prepared to expand
Mardi Ford, director of communications and marketing at Grande Ronde Hospital, La Grande, said the hospital could not disclose why a person is in the hospital due to patient privacy laws, but as of Tuesday afternoon Grande Ronde’s census — the number of patients in the hospital for any purpose — was below the threshold of the hospital’s bed limit. The average daily census is between 10 and 20 depending on the season.
The normal capacity for the hospital is 25, but in the release from the Center for Human Development, the hospital also included a statement that in an emergency situation it could expand capacity to 40. If needed, the GRH Pavilion near downtown La Grande could serve as an alternative site capable of taking another 160 additional patients.
“We’ve been preparing for this since March 2,” Ford told The Observer. “We are prepared.”
In the event that hospitals within the county were overwhelmed, Jeanne noted other Eastern Oregon hospitals may be able to help take transfers and there is additional capacity at nearby metropolitan areas such as Boise, Idaho.
“It’s certainly possible that with an outbreak and a bunch of people getting sick that you could see more people need to be hospitalized than there are there,” Jeanne said.
He noted the Oregon Health Authority has dedicated 10 additional contact tracers, two on the ground in Union County and eight working remotely, to assist the five local public health staff working on investigations.
“At this time it is enough for the outbreak,” Jeanne said. “We’ll have to keep monitoring that but we think this is enough at the time.”
The county’s count was among the lowest totals in the state a week ago with just six cases. That number jumped to 13 by Friday and passed 20 over the weekend before the 99 new cases were added Monday.
In all, 1,109 tests have been processed in Union County as of Wednesday, with 242 of those being positive and 867 negative, according to the OHA website. This means about 22% of tests have come back positive. The infection rate in the county is 0.94%, which is nearly double the next highest county in Oregon — Lincoln, which is at 0.49%. One in every 107 people in the county has tested positive for the virus.
Seven of the cases in Union County are patients who have recovered, meaning 235 of the cases are active. There have not been any deaths in the county due to the virus.
As of Tuesday, the virus had not made its way into the area’s long-term care facilities, as OHA’s list of facilities reporting staff or residents with COVID-19 did not include La Grande or Union County. Statewide, three adult foster care facilities have confirmed cases of the virus and two have suspected cases with test results pending. OHA does not list which facilities are included in this list.
Businesses closing voluntarily
Local businesses are closing their doors to protect employees and clients after reopening a little more than a month ago.
“I volunteered to close to protect my family and friends, and not put any of my clients at risk,” said Chelsea Weber, an esthetician at Skinplicity at Blue Mountain Mermaid, a salon in Elgin.
She explained even though her businesses can take precautions in protecting clients, such as frequent sanitation and prescreening customers before they enter, her line of work makes it difficult to keep a proper distance between clients.
Blue Mountain Outfitters, John Howard & Associates Real Estate and Community Kindness of Northeastern Oregon, all in downtown La Grande, announced temporary closures because of the outbreak.
“The last few months have taught me a lot about acting on personal conviction in the absence of further direction from state authorities, so we have always erred on the side of caution in our policies around sanitation and opening/closing,” said Jim Whitbeck, owner of Blue Mountain Outfitters.
“We all need to do our part to prevent the spread of the COVID-19 virus, and that includes wearing masks out in public and maintaining social distancing,” John Howard of John Howard and Associates wrote on Facebook. “Our actions do affect the community we live in, the business community and especially those who are in a compromised health condition. As a business owner, I think it’s important we be responsible and take actions ourselves rather than waiting to be told we have to by state authorities.”
Closures come with costs
Some local eating establishments also are going back to takeout and delivery only. Moy’s Dynasty Restaurant and Local Harvest Eatery and Pub, both in La Grande, and Cowboys and Angels Place and Timber’s Feedery, both in Elgin, announced they would be closing for dine-in service until further notice.
“We feel with these current outbreaks and the possibility of many more that this is our only option at this point to keep our staff and customers safe,” Bruce Rogers, owner of Local Harvest and Timber’s Feedery said. “We need to be responsible to our community and until someone really knows what is going on there is a possibility that not being responsible could make things worse.”
These closures do not come without a cost.
Weber said she worries that even if she can come back, the services she offers still may be restricted and that could mean losing clients who came to her specifically for those services. Additionally, she said those whose jobs depend on a license to work are sitting idle as “time on the meter runs” and Weber said she hopes the government will consider extending licenses.
“Whether I believe this is ‘real’ or a ‘political fight’ or not, I am going to do my part to keep those around me healthy and safe,” Weber said.
Whitbeck said the decision to close comes at a time of heavy traffic to the store.
“As a retail business entering a high traffic part of our season, we felt our staff would have to endure a high level of exposure in order for us to remain open,” he said. “That traffic also also puts us in a position to potentially help slow the spread of the current outbreak.”
Many are taking the closures on a week-by-week basis. Rogers said his restaurants are in no rush to reopen, and while it is important people continue to work, employee and customer health is the most important. Weber said she would like to see a drop in cases before she reopens her practice.
“I would certainly want to see new cases level off and existing in decline, but from everything I’ve seen this will get worse before it gets better and circumstances seems to change every 20 minutes, so I’m not in a position to set a time table,” Whitbeck said about reopening. “Other variables that will get figured in to the reopening calculus include unemployment availability for staff, general comfort level with exposure, ability to mitigate risk, and of course how the business can actually survive with the doors closed.”
The Center for Human Development in its press release Tuesday also encouraged people to take precautions to a higher level.
“Please avoid social gatherings with those not in your household,” the release states. “Continue to practice physical distancing, stay home when you are sick, wash your hands or use hand sanitizer often, and wear cloth face coverings when public.”
CHD listed three instances where a person must quarantine for 14 days: If they are a confirmed positive case, if they have been in close contact (within 6 feet for more than 15 minutes) with a confirmed positive case, or if they are symptomatic. Symptoms include “fever or chills, cough, shortness of breath or difficulty breathing, fatigue, muscle or body aches, headache, new loss of taste or smell, sore throat, congestion or runny nose, nausea or vomiting, and diarrhea.”
Tuesday afternoon, the outbreak in Union County led to La Grande Parks & Recreation immediately closing “all park restrooms, Veterans’ Memorial Pool and Summer Day Camp programs.” The release added that Morgan Lake will remain open.
Oregon is at 6,218 cases as of Wednesday afternoon, and the state has seen 183 deaths related to the virus.
Editor's note: The Observer updated the report Thursday morning to reflect the change in the Lighthouse Pentecostal Church's Facebook page.
The Bend Bulletin, EO Media Group reporter Alex Castle and Observer editor Phil Wright contributed to this article.